Carlton Town

Establishment and pre-World War I

Carlton Town was founded as Sneinton Football Club in September 1904, beginning in the amateur Notts Alliance League after having a previous application refused. The team enjoyed success in their first season; finishing runners-up to Basford United, Sneinton then moved to sign more promising locals. In May 1905, the club gained use of the Earl Manvers’ Colwick Lawn Estate, the Sneinton Cricket Club and Ground, on Colwick Road. Becoming champions in the 1905–06 season, mixed fortunes followed as key players Arthur Clamp and Andrew Mosley joined Notts County, while new tram infrastructure in the area promised better attendances at home games.

Sneinton won the League championship again in 1907–08, also reaching the first round of the Notts Alliance Cup and losing to Oxford City in the third round of the FA Amateur Cup. The club was granted membership of The Football Association on 2 November 1908. The League title was defended in 1908–09, but Sutton Town eliminated Sneinton from both of its cup competitions. Described by the Manchester Courier as "the leading amateur football club in Nottingham", Sneinton won the 1909–10 League, becoming the first team to win three consecutive titles. The following year they again reached the third round of the Amateur Cup, where they lost 6–2 to Bromley. Their playing form suffered by the end of the 1912–13 season, with the team losing several players to injury and relocation.

Interwar period

Nine Sneinton players were killed in World War I, for the duration of which the team was disbanded. The club reformed on 29 April 1919, and did well in the 1919–20 season, once more obtaining a place in the Amateur Cup's third round. Sneinton lacked the means to travel and insisted the match be played in Nottingham, securing Notts County's Meadow Lane as a venue, but they lost 8–1 to Leytonstone. Despite team rebuilding and many injuries, Sneinton finished an encouraging third in their 1920–21 League campaign. Conversely, the 1922–23 season witnessed mediocre playing form and a poor financial situation at the club. These were recurrent problems throughout the decade, except for the team becoming joint-winners of the 1925–26 Notts Alliance Cup.

The club's fortunes improved in 1931 as it reached the Amateur Cup's third round for a fourth, and final, time. Acknowledging Sneinton as a "nursery" for their professional squads, Notts County and Nottingham Forest paid for the team's travel to Stockton, where they were defeated 7–2. In May 1932, Sneinton applied to join the Notts Spartan League's First Division, securing the title on its first attempt before finishing third in the Senior Division in 1933–34 after turning an annual profit. Given the absence of financial backers, moving leagues was intended to allow the team to play at a lower standard than that of the Notts Alliance. Reviewing the 1936–37 and 1938–39 seasons, Sneinton was judged by its officials to be in good sporting and financial shape.

Sneinton revival: 1947–2002

Following another disbandment due to World War II, Sneinton reformed in July 1947, also absorbing local club Trent Rangers. According to the Nottingham Evening Post, it was "realised that a lot of hard work will be necessary to restore the ... club to the old time high position". In 1948, the team started playing on a pitch at Colwick Wood Park, thereby returning to Sneinton after contesting one season at a venue outside the district. The club moved to Division Three of the Notts Amateur League, finishing seventh in 1949–50 and with steady finances. After a loss to Bakersfield in the 1951–52 campaign, the Nottingham Football Post commented that the team "appeared to be too individualistic".

The club had achieved promotion to Division Two by 1956–57. In 1957–58, the team's prolific goal-scoring led to an undefeated run lasting almost three months. The Football Post commented that year that "the Sneintonians are doing very well", but just two years later, during the 1959–60 season, argued that the team was "lacking in a marksman" and "need[ed] more punch in attack". Illnesses and outside work commitments within its part-time squad were a challenge for the club, but the Football Post still acknowledged the high quality of Sneinton's teamwork, goalkeeping, and defence.

During 1965–66, the club struggled to field a full team at times, occasionally requiring its secretary to play. Sneinton experienced poor form in the 1967–68 season, but avoided relegation, and again transferred leagues a year later, ahead of the 1969–70 season, to rejoin Division Two of the Notts Alliance. The first season saw the team endure mediocre League performances and disciplinary issues, but by the 1976–77 campaign was described by the Football Post as "much-improved". In spite of this, Sneinton suffered some heavy defeats; the team lost 9–0 to Rolls-Royce Welfare in 1977–78, and lost by the same score to Worthington Simpsons Reserves during the following season. Sneinton won the division in 1984–85, gaining promotion to Division One; it later topped that level in 1992–93 to reach the Notts Alliance's pinnacle Senior Division.